Murray, Kentucky's Favorite Since 1979
The Proof
Is in the
Taste.
Fresh dough made daily. Brick ovens at 600°. Recipes brought from Italy by the Pagliai family — unchanged for generations.
Location
970 Chestnut Street
Murray, Kentucky
Get directions →
Phone
Groups Welcome
Spacious dining · Private rooms · Indoor playpark · Arcade · Call ahead for large groups
A True Family Restaurant
More than pizza.
A Murray institution.
Pagliai's (pronounced Polly-Eyes) has been the heart of Murray dining for decades. The Pagliai family brought their Italian recipes to Kentucky — and they haven't cut a single corner since.
We grind our own beef sirloin, make our own Italian sausage from fresh Boston butts, and slice every vegetable by hand. Our Wisconsin mozzarella comes from a family dairy that feeds its cows a special diet to guarantee the best milk every day.
Everything We Offer
Something for everyone
Pizza, Pasta & Salads
Build your own pizza from 16 fresh toppings, choose a specialty pizza, or try our pasta, wraps, salads, and sandwiches.
Free Indoor Playpark
Let the kids play while you relax. Our free indoor playpark and two game rooms mean everyone has a great time.
Meetings & Banquets
Spacious private dining rooms available for group events, meetings, birthday parties, and banquets.